i am thinking maybe the ruched one cos it has more shape on the tummy area?

I like the second one best x

I really like them both but if i was to pick one it would be the red one x

I like them both but probably the 2nd one but that's only because I don't wear a lot of red

I like the second one best x

I like the red one

xx

the red ones lovely

For me, the one on the right, but I'm not sure for you cos I don't really know what you look like xx

I prefer the one on the right, but for you i'd probably say the red one.

I'd go for the red one x

for godsake ladies, you were all meant to pick the same one

i like the red one cos i think it would be cute with leggings and a navy cardi, but i like the vintageyness of the one on the right.....hmmm............my other choice is this one which is the same as the red but in navy

yeah its a bit hard..i will describe myself......size 16 (hoorah!!!), 5'5ish, shoulder length brown hair.....bit boring really but i have no fear of colour and love a bit of cuteness, very paranoid about my still saggy tummy though - i wonder if the first one will make me look a bit preggy if the elastic is high up..hrm!

oh in fact theres a photo of me in member pics section, im about a stone heavier now

The one with the elastic waist is one of those ones that make me look pregnant, but I'm not. It you're the same you need one that has a bit of a gather round the front neckline. If that makes sense.

I'm with Shellm. The first one would make me look pregnant (although I am bigger than you). If you're worried about your tummy I'd pick the second one. Actually I prefer the second one anyway.

depends, if the elastic is high i do get tummybump but if it sits quite low its great cos it shows off your waist without letting it hang out

i ordered both in the end cos then i can try them on and take whichever one i don't like back to the store

If I did that I'd end up liking them both and keeping them both

well if i do i will cos im so clothesless at the moment and i had an adorable tunic that i shrunk to elijah size today

Just been to stalk to your pics. Think both would suit you. You look really different to how I imagined though. Don't know why because I'm sure I've seen pics of you with Elijah. I think I saw you as a female version of him.

Love your new avatar pic by the way. I love ginger hair which is a good job because Jamie seems to be getting more gingery

I would have probably ordered all 3 just to see (and knowing me i'd have kept at least 2 of them )

hahahaha ermmm elijah is so much like his daddy really - baring in mind the wedding pics are 3 years old (and before sleepless child!!!) i do look somewhat rougher these days

ginger is the new blond im sure of it, SO many little ones around here are fiery red its quite nice

We all look a lot rougher than our wedding pics! Ah I remember pre child days. That's when I didn't venture out of the house without makeup. Not even sure where the bag is now.

Probably a stereotype but aren't there supposed to be more redheads the further north you go. I think its a gorgeous colour. Better than my mousy brown

im pretty mousey too

yeah, god i wouldn't go anywhere without having at least washed my hair, put makeup on, actually thought a bit about what i was wearing.......ha ha oh well!

I like the navy one now!

I would have ordered both styles then decided once I'd tried them on. I used to do that so much with Kay's catalogue that they wrote to me saying that clearly their styles weren't right for me and perhaps I should consider ending my account!

oh no really??? hahhaha on the returns slips with next there is a 'ordered for choice' box to tick so i suppose they expect you to do it - i never would have except a girl at work does it with her entire wardrobe every season (who has time for that?!)

No way - might as well just go to the shop and try it all on there! It does my nut in with la Redoute when you want to compare but they don't all come at once!